The question usually arrives with a specific person attached. A company has found someone it needs, a lead engineer, a head of sales, a contractor who has become indispensable, and it can't pay them what a larger competitor would. The answer on the table is "equity."
That word covers several very different arrangements. Some make the person an actual owner. Some pay them as if they were an owner without giving them any ownership rights. Some aren't equity at all. The choice determines when the person pays tax, whether they get a vote and a K-1, whether contractors can participate, and what happens when someone leaves or the company sells. Getting it wrong can produce a surprise tax bill, a securities law problem, or a partner nobody intended to have.
Two questions to answer first
Do you want the person to own part of the company, or to share in its value? Real owners have rights. Depending on the entity and its governing documents, those can include information rights, voting rights, fiduciary protections, tax reporting, and a place in any sale. Many owners want to share economics with key people without sharing control. That points toward phantom equity or profit sharing rather than real equity.
What kind of entity is it? A corporation, whether taxed as a C corporation or an S corporation, can issue stock options and restricted stock. An LLC taxed as a partnership can issue profits interests. An S corporation is limited to one class of stock and can't issue profits interests at all, which narrows its options considerably.
Real equity
Stock options
A stock option is the right to buy shares later at a price fixed today, the strike price. The strike price should be at least the fair market value of the shares on the grant date. Options granted below value can fall under Section 409A, the deferred compensation rules, with harsh penalties for the holder. That is why companies that grant options get a formal valuation, commonly called a 409A valuation.
There are two types. Incentive stock options (ISOs) can go only to employees. They aren't taxed when exercised for regular income tax purposes, though the spread can trigger alternative minimum tax. If the shares are held at least two years from grant and one year from exercise, the entire gain is long-term capital gain. ISOs must be granted under a plan approved by the shareholders. Only $100,000 of options, measured by strike price, can first become exercisable in any year. An employee who leaves generally must exercise within three months to keep ISO treatment.
Nonqualified stock options (NSOs) can go to employees, contractors, advisors, and directors. The spread at exercise is ordinary income, and the company gets a matching deduction. NSOs are simpler and more flexible; ISOs are more tax-efficient for the employee.
Either way, the holder owns nothing until exercise. That is an advantage for the company: someone holding unexercised options has no shareholder rights.
Restricted stock
Restricted stock is actual stock issued now, subject to vesting. If the holder leaves before it vests, the company can buy back the unvested shares, usually at the original price. Founders and very early employees most often receive equity this way.
The critical tax step is the Section 83(b) election. The holder has 30 days from the grant to file it with the IRS, and there is no extension. With the election, the holder is taxed now on the stock's current value, often close to zero at an early-stage company, and all later appreciation is capital gain. Without it, the holder is taxed as each tranche vests, at whatever the stock is worth by then. At a company that has grown, that can be a large tax bill with no cash to pay it.
Profits interests
For an LLC taxed as a partnership, the profits interest is usually the right tool. It is a real ownership interest that shares only in value created after the grant. The company sets a threshold equal to its current value. The holder receives nothing from that existing value and participates only in growth above it.
Under Rev. Proc. 93-27 and Rev. Proc. 2001-43, receiving a profits interest for services is generally not a taxable event. The exceptions are narrow: interests tied to a substantially certain and predictable income stream, interests disposed of within two years, and interests in publicly traded partnerships. When the company later sells, the holder's gain is generally capital gain if the holding period is met. Many practitioners still file a protective 83(b) election at grant.
The trade-off is that the holder becomes a partner, and that changes the employment relationship. The IRS position, stated in Rev. Rul. 69-184, is that a partner can't also be an employee of the partnership. A W-2 employee who receives a profits interest can move onto K-1 reporting, with self-employment tax, estimated payments, and changes to benefits eligibility. There are structural ways to manage this, but they have to be planned before the grant. Partners can also be allocated taxable income in years the company distributes no cash, so the operating agreement should provide for tax distributions.
An S corporation can't grant profits interests. It can restructure through an F reorganization into a holding company that owns an operating LLC, and the LLC can then grant them.
Sharing value without ownership
Phantom equity
Phantom equity, sometimes called phantom stock or "ghost equity," is a contract, not ownership. The company promises to pay cash equal to the value of a set number of notional units, usually when the company is sold. A full-value plan pays the whole value of the units. An appreciation-only plan pays just the growth since the grant date and works like a stock appreciation right.
The holder is taxed at ordinary income rates when paid, and the company deducts the payment. Nothing is taxed at grant. The holder gets no vote, no K-1, and no information rights beyond what the plan provides. For an owner who wants to share the upside of a sale without adding anyone to the cap table, phantom equity is often the cleanest answer. It works for any entity type. S corporations can use it without creating a second class of stock, as long as the plan is drafted within Treas. Reg. § 1.1361-1(b)(4).
Two cautions apply. First, phantom plans are deferred compensation. They must comply with Section 409A or fit an exemption, and payment triggers such as a sale have to track the statute's definitions. A failure costs the holder an additional 20% tax plus interest. Second, a buyer treats the payout as a cost of the deal, so it comes out of the owners' proceeds at closing. Model that number before the grant.
Profit sharing
Profit sharing is a cash bonus paid from the company's profits, either a fixed percentage or a discretionary pool. It is the simplest arrangement on this list. The employee receives ordinary income, the company takes a deduction, and nobody gains ownership or complicated plan documents.
It rewards this year's results, not long-term value, and it pays nothing extra when the company sells. Retention comes from requiring the person to be employed on the payment date. Don't confuse it with a profits interest, which is ownership, or with a qualified retirement profit-sharing plan, which is a different arrangement governed by ERISA.
Side by side
| Entity | Ownership | Taxed at grant | Taxed at payout or sale | Contractors | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ISOs | Corporation | After exercise | No | AMT possible at exercise; capital gain on qualifying sale | No |
| NSOs | Corporation | After exercise | No | Ordinary income at exercise; capital gain after | Yes |
| Restricted stock | Corporation | Yes | With 83(b), on current value | Capital gain on sale | Yes |
| Profits interest | LLC taxed as partnership | Yes | Generally no | Generally capital gain on sale | Yes |
| Phantom equity | Any | No | No | Ordinary income when paid | Yes |
| Profit sharing | Any | No | No | Ordinary income when paid | Yes |
Contractors and securities law
Contractors can receive everything on this list except ISOs. Any grant of real equity is also a sale of securities, even when no money changes hands, so it needs an exemption from registration. For private companies, Rule 701 generally covers compensatory grants to employees, directors, and consultants who are individuals providing bona fide services. State securities law applies as well. Phantom equity and profit sharing are generally not securities offerings, which is one more reason companies use them for contractors.
Vesting
Vesting is what turns a grant into an incentive. Unvested equity is forfeited when the person leaves, so the unvested balance is a cost of walking away. The schedule should run at least as long as the stretch you most need the person for.
Time-based vesting is the default. The venture-market standard is four years with a one-year cliff: nothing vests in the first year, 25% vests at the one-year mark, and the rest vests monthly or quarterly. Established operating companies often use three to five years. The cliff protects the company from a hire who doesn't work out.
Performance vesting ties equity to results, such as revenue, a product launch, or a customer target. It aligns the grant with what the company needs, but the metric must be defined precisely. Vague milestones are a common source of disputes.
Exit vesting means nothing vests until the company is sold. It is common with phantom equity and suits owners whose real goal is keeping a team together through a sale.
Acceleration decides what happens at a sale. Single-trigger acceleration vests everything when the company sells. Double-trigger acceleration requires a sale followed by the person's termination without cause, or resignation for good reason, within a set period. Buyers strongly prefer double-trigger because single-trigger removes the retention they are paying for.
Departure terms matter as much as the schedule. The documents should say:
- what happens to vested equity when someone leaves;
- whether the company can buy it back, and at what price;
- how long a departing option holder has to exercise;
- whether a termination for cause forfeits vested phantom equity.
Many plans pay fair value to someone who leaves on good terms and less to someone terminated for cause. If a plan conditions payment on not competing, Tennessee's rules on restrictive covenants apply; see our discussion of Tennessee's noncompete framework.
What the company gets from a well-built plan
Retention. Unvested value gives key people a concrete reason to stay through the hard stretches.
Cash conservation. A company that can't match big-company salaries can compete with upside instead.
Alignment. People who share in value tend to act like owners, and performance vesting points them at specific goals.
Control. Phantom equity and profit sharing keep governance with the owners. Vesting and buyback rights keep equity from ending up with people who left years ago.
A cleaner sale. Buyers diligence every equity promise. Written plans with defined change-in-control terms survive diligence. An offer letter promising "5% when we sell" often becomes a lawsuit, and it usually surfaces at the worst possible moment.
Mistakes we see most often
- Promising a percentage in an offer letter before deciding what the instrument is.
- Missing the 30-day 83(b) deadline.
- Granting options without a current valuation.
- Giving a W-2 employee a profits interest without addressing payroll and benefits.
- Issuing an S corporation employee shares with different economic rights, which risks the S election.
- Granting equity without board or member approval, or without a written plan.
Most of these are inexpensive to prevent and expensive to fix. Decide what you want the person to have, pick the instrument that delivers it for your entity, and put the vesting and departure terms in writing before anyone signs an offer letter.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a profits interest and profit sharing? A profits interest is an ownership interest in an LLC taxed as a partnership that shares only in value created after the grant. Profit sharing is a cash bonus paid from profits, with no ownership.
What is phantom equity? A contract that pays cash equal to the value, or the increase in value, of a set number of notional units, usually when the company is sold. It is taxed as ordinary income when paid and must comply with Section 409A.
Can independent contractors receive equity? Yes, except incentive stock options, which are limited to employees. Contractors can receive nonqualified options, restricted stock, profits interests, and phantom equity.
What is a one-year cliff? Nothing vests during the first year. At the one-year mark a first block vests, commonly 25% on a four-year schedule, and the rest vests monthly or quarterly after that.

Shareholder · Nashville
Business and intellectual property counsel to founders, creative companies, and technology businesses.
This article is general information about the law as of its publication date, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The law changes; consult counsel about your specific situation.